Blog
- A September to Remember
-
The impact Wall Street will have on Main Street is just now becoming a bit clearer but uncertainty still reigns. Here are the stories of six Austin professionals who have been impacted by the financial crisis or managed to avoid it — at least for now.Premium content from Austin Business Journal by ABJ Staff
Date: Sunday, October 5, 2008To say the past few weeks in the business world have been tumultuous would be an understatement.
Since the federal government seized control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac on Sept. 8, a flurry of buyouts, bailouts and failures have turned the national economy upside down. Lehman Bros. is in Chapter 11. Merrill Lynch is takingBank of America under its wing. Taxpayers now own insurance giant AIG . Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs have changed their business plans. Washington Mutual is now JPMorgan Chase & Co. , and Wachovia was snapped up by Citigroup . And during all this, Congress wrangled over a $700 billion bailout plan — and while it did the stock markets recorded some historic gains and loses.
How have Wall Street’s woes affected Main Street so far? This week the Austin Business Journal spoke to six local professionals — from a variety of industries and at a variety of levels — to uncover how the financial crisis is affecting them (see pages 14-15).
For many on so-called Main Street, it’s been business as usual. For others, things have changed. But in almost all cases, the clouded future of the financial industry has local business owners, economists and analysts expecting things to get worse before they get better. By most accounts, small businesses in particular — the backbone of Austin’s economy — are expected to be hit hardest in the coming weeks and months as lending standards tighten further.
Where Wall Street meets Main Street
The Realtor
Robert Grunnah, founder of Castle Hill Investments, a local real estate investment, brokerage and development firm, says home buyers are slowing down and their calls are “in a deep freeze” amid the recent financial turmoil.
“It’s eerily quiet,” he says. “I think buyers are petrified. It’s a very short-term human emotion: I’m not going to make any big decisions right now. … There is tremendous fear based on herd mentality, and people exaggerate the negative when it’s a fearful time.”
Buyers’ offers are coming in 10 percent to 20 percent below asking price, and they are being tougher on inspections and asking for larger repair allowances, Grunnah says. “Buyers are looking for big excuses for price cuts because the sky is falling.”
Some brokers, meanwhile, are experiencing a windfall because seller loyalty to their agents has deteriorated as sellers get nervous and impatient.
Grunnah predicts average sales volumes for brokerage businesses will fall 20 to 30 percent, but “it’s fine as long as you can survive. Some of the more established agents are seeing increased business because of it.”
Grunnah says he’s not panicked because Austin’s market remains somewhat insulated.
“We are definitely within a 10 percent bubble or 5 percent bubble,” he says. “We have such strong job growth and population growth, and prices didn’t get too high to begin with. I’m thanking my lucky stars that I’m in a market as dynamic as Austin.”
By Jean Kwon
The Car Salesman
Car dealers’ inventory and pricing haven’t changed much in the past two weeks, but the ability to secure financing has changed for some would-be car buyers.
One car dealer says good credit doesn’t necessarily mean financing is assured now that banks are having problems with liquidity.
“People who we were getting financed [with no problem], they aren’t even being considered now,” says the dealer, who asked not to be named out of concern for discouraging customers. “It’s not just credit, it’s advances too. … General Motors last week said their business is down 10 to 15 percent just because of that. It’s got nothing to do with the wants and desires of the marketplace. Is [the financial crisis] affecting our business? Absolutely.”
Meanwhile, borrowing rates have risen by several percentage points at some dealerships in the last couple weeks, the dealer says.
But other dealers aren’t sure the turmoil on Wall Street will have a direct effect on their businesses. Kyle Chapman, head of Kyle Chapman Motor Sales, says he’s noticed a steady rise in customers with bad credit over the past 20 years. But the impact of the last two weeks remains to be seen, he says.
Anxious to see how the next few weeks pan out, Chapman says his car lots’ future revolves around “what the government gets done, how it affects the big banks and how they affect the little banks,” Chapman says.
By Kate Harrington
The Retailer
For Stephanie Coultress, recent events on Wall Street have made life on Second Street surreal.
Coultress has run Estilo in Austin’s Second Street District for three years, just about the time her business’s performance was anticipated to hit a financial sweet spot. Instead, Coultress says she’s keeping a nervous eye on her loans.
While she says her loan terms haven’t changed on her and sales have been steady enough to keep up with loan payments, she can’t do much more than that.
“I’m only able to sustain the loan payment and make it,” she says. “You have to figure out what can go 60 days and what needs to be paid first, like rent and payroll.”
And whether Coultress’ clientele is feeling an actual pinch or having a purely psychological reaction to the last two weeks of turmoil in the markets, she has noticed a difference in client behavior recently.
“What’s sustained us has been our local customers who are loyal. That’s how we’ve continued to stay in business,” she says. “I used to get 20 people a day, now I get five a day. There are customers who used to spend $3,000 a transaction and now spend half that.”
Coultress says her sales are 50 to 60 percent below where she’d projected for this point in the year, but she estimates that sales will bounce back 50 percent by the holiday season in 2009. Until then, Coultress says she’s aware that she could be watching the fundamental face of business change as the country’s financial troubles play out.
“It’s surreal and scary, and probably the worst time to own a business,” she says. “I’m lucky I’ve been open for three years and in that first year, I established a good clientele. … Without them, I wouldn’t be in business.”
By Kate Harrington
The Investment Adviser
Pierre Johnson, a financial adviser at Edward Jones, says it’s been business as usual for the past several weeks — but not because his clients aren’t worried.
Although he’s been working a little more after hours and on weekends, Johnson’s been steadfast in his counsel to clients.
Having been in the industry nearly 12 years and having experienced market corrections, Johnson says being proactive is key, as is ensuring clients are diversifying and that their allocations fit their objectives.
“Nothing is foolproof, but the idea is to put strategies in place to allow portfolios to weather market conditions,” he says. “If something needs to be changed, you do it based on objectives and not emotions.”
Johnson says he’s gotten calls from clients to “reconfirm” the advice he’s shared with them.
“No one has called panicking, saying, ‘Let’s sell everything,’” he adds.
Johnson says he’s told business owners they should be reviewing their investment policy statements and educational programs on the design of 401Ks and other retirement savings plans.
“This would be an appropriate time to be proactive about that because participants will want to know if their balance is going down, and it could just be an issue of education or fund selection,” he says.
Johnson says clients look to him to feel a sense of confidence, and he’s had no difficulty offering that peace of mind.
He relates the situation to an airplane ride he took when the pilot said there would be turbulence while steering around a storm.
“It was pretty bumpy for 45 minutes, but there was nothing you could do about it; same thing here,” he says. “There’s turbulence in the market, yes. And is it emotional? Yes. But it’s something you have to deal with. You just need to make sure your investments fit with your long-term objectives.”
By Jean Kwon
The Credit Union Executive
Laurie Roberts and her team of mortgage advisers have had their hands full dealing with natural and man-made disasters.
Roberts, president of Members Home Advisor, University Federal Credit Union’s wholly-owned subsidiary, already had her professional life turned upside down by Hurricane Ike, which destroyed UFCU’s Galveston branch.
Now the human-generated problems of national financial institutions such as Merrill Lynch, Washington Mutual, Wachovia and others have trickled down to the mortgage business’s frontline staffers.
Mortgage lending professionals are spending about twice as much time counseling prospective home buyers as usual, Roberts says.
“Our advice hasn’t changed, but people need more explanation and more information about the market and home prices,” she says.
The difference is that Central Texans are open to the advice, Roberts says.
“They want the advice now,” she says. “Before … it was ‘Well, I’ll go down the street and they’ll give me what I want.’”
Because the credit union refrained from subprime lending, it has been able to get through the mortgage mess relatively unscathed, and that has placed UFCU in a trusted position with consumers, Roberts says.
That doesn’t mean there haven’t been challenges.
“Where it really affects us is in our ability to sell loans on the secondary market. We’ve seen the pendulum swing from anything goes to almost nobody can get one,” Roberts says.
Roberts says the bank has slowed in the last few weeks. While fall is typically a slow period for the credit union, customers are also taking a step back, she says.
“I think so much depends on what this bailout looks like overall,” she says.
By Sandra Zaragoza
The Nonprofit Head
Walter Moreau, executive director of Foundation Communities, views the flurry of problems on Wall Street with a mixture of disbelief and anger.
“If you would have told me a year ago that our small nonprofit would be in business and huge financial powerhouses would be gone — that would’ve been unbelievable to me,” Moreau says.
The loose underwriting standards that led to the national mortgage crisis are also hard for Moreau to digest. Financial risk is something Foundation Communities, a real estate nonprofit serving low-income people through housing and education, has worked hard to minimize.
“We have a strong balance sheet, and we are very conservative about borrowing money because we want to be around Austin a long, long time,” Moreau says.
Five of Foundation Communities’ apartment complexes, which house low-income and homeless individuals, have commercial mortgages from Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and one other troubled financial institution.
Moreau is waiting to hear what effect, if any, the changes at those mortgage companies will have on the nonprofit’s loans.
But after more than a week of negative news from Wall Street, Moreau has been hearing positive things from lending partners who are confirming that funding is still available for the nonprofit’s future projects. He even received a cold call from one major national lender saying it would be willing to extend a line of credit. And this week, the nonprofit’s board approved a $750,000 loan from Wells Fargo to help with green building practices.
“Underwriting has gotten a little tougher, so have debt coverage requirements. But it’s probably just closer to our own internal standards,” he says.
“We are still looking to grow and be realistic about new projects. We are not giving up,” Moreau says.
By Sandra Zaragoza
See also the Opinion section of the ABJ for the week of October 3, 2008, for related stories.
September to remember
Sept. 8 The Federal Housing Finance Agency takes over embattled mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac amid declining shareholder confidence that sent their stocks spiraling downward earlier in the summer.
Sept. 15 Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. files Chapter 11 bankruptcy after failing to secure a last-minute acquisition deal.
Bank of America Corp. agrees to buy troubled financial services group Merrill Lynch & Co. for $50 billion in stock.
Sept. 16 The U.S. Treasury Department and the Federal Reserve orchestrate an $85 billion bailout of insurance giant American International Group Inc., drawing the ire of lawmakers and Main Street.
Sept. 19 In a move to bolster investor confidence, the Securities and Exchange Commission announces a two-week ban on short selling in 799 financial companies.
Sept. 22 Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. abandon their status as investment banks in an attempt to avoid the fate of former industry giants Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch.
Sept. 25 A day after the $700 billion bailout plan was hatched and President Bush spoke to the country about the gravity of the financial debacle, Congressional leaders get bogged down in the details, stalling the plan.
Late in the day, federal regulators seize control of Washington Mutual Inc. and strike a deal to sell most of its holdings to JPMorgan Chase & Co. The largest banking collapse in U.S. history caused financial stocks to plummet on Friday.
Sept. 28 Congress and the White House reach resolution on the $700 billion federal bailout bill. The unprecedented initiative, known as the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, is intended to free the flow of credit by allowing financial institutions to off-load their nonperforming mortgage assets.
Sept. 29 Citigroup Inc. agrees to buy Wachovia’s banking operations for $2.1 billion.
Early in the afternoon, the U.S. House rejects the bailout bill, causing a rush on Wall Street that sent the Dow Jones industrial average down 771 points, only to shoot up again the next day by 485 points.
- People On the Move
-
Featured Story
Bob Richards | President of Central Texas Operations, TDIndustries
Duties: Geographically, Richards’ scope extends from San Antonio to Waco.
Experience: Richards has been with TDIndustries, a construction company, for 10 years. Most recently, he was working as the executive vice president of the company’s Central Texas operations.
Education: Bachelor’s degree from Dallas Baptist University.
Architecture and Engineering
Ben Butler has joined Hailey Group Architects + Urbanists as a project manager. Butler was previously with LWPB Architecture in Oklahoma City. Ben May has joined Hailey Group as a project manager. May has 10 years’ experience in high-end residential and multifamily design and development. Davey McEathron has joined Hailey Group as an architect intern. McEathron is a graduate of Portland State University.
Bill McCann has been promoted to a senior project manager at HS&A. McCann joined HS&A in 2007 as a project manager.
Associations and Nonprofits
Angela Funke has joined Texas Campus Compact as director of communications. She was previously a coordinator at the Austin American-Stateman’s Homework Helpline.
Banking and Finance
Thomas Braasch has joined Capital CDC as the director of business development.
Charles Burgess has been promoted to vice president of the corporate banking department of the Downtown Austin Financial Center of Frost Bank. Burgess was previously an assistant vice president. Lee Harle has been promoted to a relationship banking officer in the corporate banking department of the Westlake Hills branch of Frost Bank. Harle was previously a relationship banker. George McGraw has been promoted to a relationship banker of corporate banking at the Downtown Austin Financial Center. McGraw was previously a relationship banker. Barbara Shaffer has been promoted to vice president of the corporate banking department at the Pecan Park branch. Shaffer was previously an assistant vice president. Marie Sanchez has been promoted to vice president of the corporate banking department at the 26 Doors location. Sanchez was previously an assistant vice president.
Construction
Glenn Biles has been named tile and stone divisional manager at Commercial Flooring Systems. Edwina Sansom has been named vice president of operations at Commercial Flooring Systems. Sansom was previously a senior estimator with Constructors & Associates.
Consulting and Marketing
Thad Getterman has joined Apogee Search as a developer.
Health Care
Eric Dai has joined Eye Physicians of Austin as an ophthalmologist. Dai just performed his medical residency at the University of Texas’ Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas.
Steve Wood has been promoted to executive vice president at Harden Healthcare. Wood previously served as the chief financial officer. Scott Ellyson has been named the chief financial officer for Harden Healthcare. Ellyson was previously senior vice president of health care investment with Houlihan Lokey Howard & Zukin. Ben Hanson has beeen named senior vice president and general counsel for Harden Healthcare. Hanson was previously general counsel and secretary with DMX Holdings. Concurrently, he was principal and general counsel for Capstar Partners.
Paul Hennessy has been promoted to market manager of the rehabilitation outreach division of St. David’s HealthCare. Hennessy has more than 15 years experience in health care administration and health care marketing and has been with St. David’s for five years, most recently serving as a marketing representative. Kathlene Lambert has joined St. David’s HealthCare as the director of outreach and development for rehabilitation services. Lambert previously held a similar positon with Sarasota Memorial HealthCare System in Florida.
Law
Randall Glenn has been named a principal at Lloyd Gosselink Rochelle & Townsend and will lead the transactions practice group. Glenn was previously with Jackson Walker.
Real Estate
Brittani Johnson has joined Castle Hill Investments as a sales associate. Heather Kight has joined Castle Hill Investments as a sales associate.
Chuck Reger has joined CB Richard Ellis Inc. as a senior real estate manager. Reger most recently held the position of director of property management with Hughes Capital Management.
Austin Duplexes
Austin Fourplexes